Martin Nikolaus Stienen, Nicolai Maldaner, Marketa Sosnova, Holger Joswig, Marco Vincenzo Corniola, Luca Regli, Gerhard Hildebrandt, Karl Schaller, Oliver Pascal Gautschi
Neurospine 2020;17(1):270-280. Published online January 26, 2020
Objective The patient-reported outcome measure (PROM)-based evaluation in lumbar degenerative disc disease (DDD) is today’s gold standard but has limitations. We studied the impact of lower extremity motor deficits (LEMDs) on PROMs and a new objective outcome measure.
Methods We evaluated patients with lumbar DDD from a prospective 2-center database. LEMDs were graded according to the British Medical Research Council (BMRC; 5 [normal] –0 [no movement]). The PROM-based evaluation included pain (visual analogue scale), disability (Oswestry Disability Index [ODI] & Roland-Morris Disability Index [RMDI]), and health-related quality of life (HRQoL; Short-Form 12 physical component summary/mental component summary & EuroQol-5D index). Objective functional impairment (OFI) was determined as age- and sex-adjusted Timed-Up and Go (TUG) test value.
Results One hundred five of 375 patients (28.0%) had a LEMD. Patients with LEMD had slightly higher disability (ODI: 52.8 vs. 48.2, p = 0.025; RMDI: 12.6 vs. 11.3, p = 0.034) but similar pain and HRQoL scores. OFI T-scores were significantly higher in patients with LEMD (144.2 vs. 124.3, p = 0.006). When comparing patients with high- (BMRC 0–2) vs. low-grade LEMD (BMRC 3–4), no difference was evident for the PROM-based evaluation (all p > 0.05) but patients with high-grade LEMD had markedly higher OFI T-scores (280.9 vs. 136.0, p = 0.001). Patients with LEMD had longer TUG test times and OFI T-scores than matched controls without LEMDs.
Conclusion Our data suggest that PROMs fail to sufficiently account for LEMD-associated disability, which is common and oftentimes bothersome to patients. The objective functional evaluation with the TUG test appears to be more sensitive to LEMD-associated disability. An objective functional evaluation of patients with LEMD appears reasonable.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
Association of oxidative stress with postural control and functional outcomes in lumbar degenerative disease: An exploratory cross-sectional study Yuta Yamazaki, Hidetoshi Nojiri, Noriaki Aita, Eriko Kitahara, Ryosuke Takahashi, Muneaki Ishijima, Toshiyuki Fujiwara Journal of Orthopaedic Science.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
Objectively measured physical activity following lumbar decompression surgery: systematic review and meta-analysis Sree Kanakala, Alisha Mahmud, Iihan Ali, Hassan Tahir, Riese Patel, Milos Brkljac, Tim Lindsay Scientific Reports.2026;[Epub] CrossRef
Impact of Drop Foot Recovery on Patient-Reported Outcomes following Surgery for Lumbar Degenerative Disease Tatsuya Yamamoto, Momotaro Kawai, Tomohisa Tabata, Yohei Takahashi, Jun Ogawa Spine Surgery and Related Research.2026; 10(3): 432. CrossRef
Reliable outcome parameters in patients with lumbar radiculopathy attributed to disc herniation: an observational study Giannina Bianchi, Christian Zweifel, Erich Hohenauer, Joseph Alvin Ramos Santos, Ron Clijsen Frontiers in Musculoskeletal Disorders.2025;[Epub] CrossRef
Preoperative motor weakness and the impact on patient reported outcomes in lateral lumbar interbody fusion Aayush Kaul, Andrea M. Roca, Fatima N. Anwar, Jacob C. Wolf, Ishan Khosla, Alexandra C. Loya, Srinath S. Medakkar, Vincent P. Federico, Arash J. Sayari, Gregory D. Lopez, Kern Singh Journal of Clinical Neuroscience.2024; 125: 7. CrossRef
ACUTE RADIATING LOW BACK PAIN IMPACT ON ROUTINE AND FUNCTION OF THE BRAZILIAN POPULATION: A CROSS-SECTIONAL STUDY GUILHERME HENRIQUE PORCEBAN, ALEXANDRE FELIPE FRANÇA FILHO, RENATO HIROSHI SALVIONI UETA, DAVID DEL CURTO, EDUARDO BARROS PUERTAS, MARCEL JUN SUGAWARA TAMAOKI Acta Ortopédica Brasileira.2023;[Epub] CrossRef
Preoperative Motor Function Associated with Short-Term Gain of Health-Related Quality of Life after Surgery for Lumbar Degenerative Disease: A Pilot Prospective Cohort Study in Japan Yuya Ishibashi, Yosuke Tomita, Shigeyuki Imura, Nobuyuki Takeuchi Healthcare.2023; 11(24): 3103. CrossRef
Association of Medical Comorbidities With Objective Functional Impairment in Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease Victor E. Staartjes, Holger Joswig, Marco V. Corniola, Karl Schaller, Oliver P. Gautschi, Martin N. Stienen Global Spine Journal.2022; 12(6): 1184. CrossRef
External Validation of the Minimum Clinically Important Difference in the Timed-up-and-go Test After Surgery for Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease Nicolai Maldaner, Marketa Sosnova, Michal Ziga, Anna M. Zeitlberger, Oliver Bozinov, Oliver P. Gautschi, Astrid Weyerbrock, Luca Regli, Martin N. Stienen Spine.2022; 47(4): 337. CrossRef
Psychometric Properties of the Scoliosis Research Society Questionnaire (Version 22r) Domains Among Adults With Spinal Deformity: A Rasch Measurement Theory Analysis Kati Kyrölä, Susanna Hiltunen, Mikko M. Uimonen, Jari Ylinen, Arja Häkkinen, Jussi P. Repo Neurospine.2022; 19(2): 422. CrossRef
External Validation of the Timed Up and Go Test as Measure of Objective Functional Impairment in Patients With Lumbar Degenerative Disc Disease Martin N Stienen, Nicolai Maldaner, Marketa Sosnova, Anna M Zeitlberger, Michal Ziga, Astrid Weyerbrock, Oliver Bozinov, Oliver P Gautschi Neurosurgery.2021; 88(2): E142. CrossRef
A New Possible Standard in Evaluating Lower Extremity Motor Weakness Kern Singh Neurospine.2020; 17(1): 285. CrossRef
The Bull or the Horn – What Are Outcomes Data? James Harrop Neurospine.2020; 17(1): 281. CrossRef
Does the Rise of Objective Measure of Functional Impairment Mean the Fall of PROMs? Satoshi Yamaguchi Neurospine.2020; 17(1): 283. CrossRef
Subjective and Objective Measures of Symptoms, Function, and Outcome in Patients With Degenerative Spine Disease Nicolai Maldaner, Martin Nikolaus Stienen Arthritis Care & Research.2020; 72(S10): 183. CrossRef
Physical Performance Tests Provide Distinct Information in Both Predicting and Assessing Patient-Reported Outcomes Following Lumbar Spine Surgery Hiral Master, Jacquelyn S. Pennings, Rogelio A. Coronado, Abigail L. Henry, Michael T. O’Brien, Christine M. Haug, Richard L. Skolasky, Lee H. Riley, Brian J. Neuman, Joseph S. Cheng, Oran S. Aaronson, Clinton J. Devin, Stephen T. Wegener, Kristin R. Arch Spine.2020; 45(23): E1556. CrossRef
Normative data of a smartphone app–based 6-minute walking test, test-retest reliability, and content validity with patient-reported outcome measures Lazar Tosic, Elior Goldberger, Nicolai Maldaner, Marketa Sosnova, Anna M. Zeitlberger, Victor E. Staartjes, Pravesh S. Gadjradj, Hubert A. J. Eversdijk, Ayesha Quddusi, Maria L. Gandía-González, Jamasb Joshua Sayadi, Atman Desai, Luca Regli, Oliver P. Gau Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine.2020; 33(4): 480. CrossRef
Evaluation of the 6-minute walking test as a smartphone app-based self-measurement of objective functional impairment in patients with lumbar degenerative disc disease Nicolai Maldaner, Marketa Sosnova, Anna M. Zeitlberger, Michal Ziga, Oliver P. Gautschi, Luca Regli, Astrid Weyerbrock, Martin N. Stienen, _ _ Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine.2020; 33(6): 779. CrossRef
First
Prev
