Since introducing full-endoscopic spine surgery in our department, I have found that choosing between foraminal and interlaminar access is rarely straightforward. This choice determines which neural structures are at risk, how much bone must be removed, and how reliably decompression can be verified. Both approaches are complementary tools that surgeons must master, rather than competing techniques.
In this issue of
Neurospine, the authors [
1] combine a structured narrative literature review with a debate on transforaminal full-endoscopic lumbar discectomy (TELD) and interlaminar full-endoscopic lumbar discectomy (IELD). They compare the arguments for each approach across 7 domains: learning curve and training, technical feasibility, patient selection, clinical and radiological outcomes, complications, cost-effectiveness, and reoperation and revision. An accompanying international survey examines approach selection across 25 clinical scenarios. A total of 172 surgeons responded, 157 of whom could be assigned to 38 countries. Together, these findings show where the literature and clinical practice converge and where the choice of approach remains unsettled.
The synthesized evidence does not establish the universal superiority of either technique. Approach selection depends on anatomy and lesion characteristics, a conclusion consistent with the survey findings. Beyond fragment location, relevant factors include the direction and extent of migration, calcification, bony access constraints, previous surgery, and segmental stability. Both techniques achieve favorable clinical outcomes in the studies presented. Small differences in pain and functional scores do not establish a consistent, clinically meaningful advantage for either approach. However, robust long-term comparisons of anatomically comparable lesions remain limited [
1].
The approaches also differ in their risk profiles. The access-related risks of TELD primarily concern the exiting nerve root and dorsal root ganglion, and the procedure often requires more fluoroscopy [
2]. IELD involves operating in close proximity to the dura and the traversing nerve root. One cited meta-analysis suggests that dural tears are more frequent with IELD, whereas overall complication rates show no consistent difference between the approaches [
3]. The type, severity, and consequences of a complication therefore deserve as much attention as its frequency.
Regarding the learning curve, the authors emphasize that published case-number thresholds reflect different endpoints and training backgrounds and therefore cannot serve as universal measures of competence. Neither approach has a consistent economic advantage, as costs and resource use depend on the healthcare setting. Revision surgery requires consideration of the current pathology and the anatomical changes caused by the index procedure. Comparative long-term reoperation rates, however, remain insufficiently characterized.
The survey provides clear examples of anatomy-related preferences. For foraminal herniations from L1–2 through L4–5, 83.1%–86.6% of respondents favored TELD. For extraforaminal herniations, agreement was 91.3% at L3–4 and 80.2% at L5–S1. Central L1–2 herniation reached the threshold only among more experienced surgeons (≥5 years, 81.4% vs. <5 years 63.0%). IELD was preferred by 88.4% of respondents for both central and paracentral herniations at L5–S1. Agreement favoring IELD reached 70.3% for caudally migrated fragments at L4–5 and 83.7% for cranially migrated fragments behind the vertebral body at L5–S1, although the L4–5 consensus was observed in only one experience subgroup.
Preferences were less uniform for common presentations at L4–5: 49.7% of respondents favored IELD for central herniations and 52.9% for paracentral herniations. Both proportions fell below the predefined 70% consensus threshold. Responses were particularly divided for foraminal herniation at L5–S1 in the presence of a high iliac crest: 28.5% selected TELD, 26.2% IELD, and 29.7% a contralateral approach. Overall, 13 of the 25 scenarios did not reach consensus.
These figures describe stated preferences rather than actual treatment decisions or differences in effectiveness. The case descriptions were text-based and lacked imaging, an essential component of approach selection. Recruitment through personal networks further limits the representativeness of the sample, and the response rate could not be calculated. Of all respondents (N=172), 59.3% were from Asia and 11.6% from Europe. The predefined 70% threshold, borrowed from Delphi research, indicates agreement rather than a level of evidence; no Delphi process was conducted. Years of experience also provide an incomplete measure of approach-specific competence, particularly because procedural volumes for each technique were not recorded. The literature review likewise lacks a formal risk-of-bias assessment.
These results are best interpreted as a gradient rather than a binary classification. With n=172, the 95% confidence interval around a proportion of 70% has a margin of error of approximately 7 percentage points. Calcified foraminal L4–5 herniation, with 68.0% agreement favoring TELD, is classified as a scenario without consensus, whereas caudally migrated L4–5 fragments, with 70.3% agreement favoring IELD, meet the consensus threshold. Upper lumbar central herniation reached the threshold only among more experienced surgeons (81.4% vs. 63.0%), whereas for calcified central L4–5 herniation, IELD was favored without reaching the threshold (IELD 65.1% vs. TELD 13.4%). The direction, strength, and stability of agreement matter more than the cutoff alone.
A key contribution of this work is its effort to derive practical criteria for approach selection from both the literature and the international survey. It also identifies unresolved clinical scenarios that warrant further investigation. A lack of consensus may reflect insufficient evidence or the availability of several reasonable options; the survey alone cannot distinguish between these possibilities. Greater uniformity in approach selection would therefore represent progress only if it led to better patient outcomes.
From a training perspective, stated preference cannot be separated from technical competence, as the authors acknowledge. In my surgical experience, the choice of corridor is shaped as much by the learning curve as by the anatomy, and surgeons tend to extend the use of the approach they learned first. Free choice requires proficiency in both corridors, assessed through completeness of decompression, complications, and patient-reported recovery rather than case numbers or operative time. Proficiency-based progression offers a suitable framework [
4,
5]. Only then can survey data help distinguish clinical judgment from the influence of training history.
Future studies should record the rationale for approach selection and surgeons’ experience with the chosen technique alongside imaging findings. Comparative studies require adequate surgical expertise in both treatment arms and should assess functional recovery, complications, and the long-term need for revision. Training should address the reasoning behind approach selection as well as technical execution. This study encourages surgeons to reconsider their preferences in individual cases: Which approach permits safe and complete decompression in a given setting, and what level of experience is required to achieve it?
NOTES
-
Conflict of Interest
The author has nothing to disclose.
REFERENCES
- 1. Pholprajug P, Ultarnpatumros T, Kavishwar RA, et al. Interlaminar versus transforaminal full-endoscopic lumbar discectomy for lumbar disc herniation: a structured debate and international practice patterns. Neurospine 2026;23:803-28.
- 2. Jitpakdee K, Liu Y, Kotheeranurak V, et al. Transforaminal versus interlaminar endoscopic lumbar discectomy for lumbar disc herniation: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Global Spine J 2023;13:575-87.
- 3. Yin J, Jiang Y, Nong L, et al. Transforaminal approach versus interlaminar approach: a meta-analysis of operative complication of percutaneous endoscopic lumbar discectomy. Medicine (Baltimore) 2020;99:e20709.
- 4. De Groote R, Puliatti S, Amato M, et al. Proficiency-based progression training for robotic surgery skills training: a randomized clinical trial. BJU Int 2022;130:528-35.
- 5. Mazzone E, Puliatti S, Amato M, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis on the impact of proficiency-based progression simulation training on performance outcomes. Ann Surg 2021;274:281-9.
Citations
Citations to this article as recorded by
